Just Shoot Me! - Season 4 Episode 16
The Pirate of Love

While attending one of Ninas sex addict therapy sessions, Finch overhears ex-wife Adrienne telling the story of a recurring fantasy: Finch in a pirate suit. He soon sneaks into her apartment to try it out, only to discover her new boyfriend: a cop. Meanwhile, Elliott and Maya struggle against Jacks intimidation to buy cookies for his daughters private school.