The One That Got Away - Season 1 Episode 5
Really, Portal?! Really!?

As the pool party unravels, The Portal reopens for Jeff and Kasey. Jeff gets a coworker with a crush, and Kasey’s cheesy hometown neighbor wants a chance at love. The Arrivals convince Taylor that Ashley might be trouble. Vinces romance with one of his Arrivals goes sky-high, causing jealousy back at the house. Finally, Allyssa has a meltdown when The Portal serves her a less-than-ideal Arrival.